What a Waste of time absolute joke

take nothing away from catalans they realised he was inept and took advantage.

Never gives us the rub of the green on 50/50 decisions. Not entirely sure why he just let the clock run down at the end either.



Oh and shoulders must start at the ears for Cas players, utterly speechless as to why the continual grapple tackles went unpunished in the first half. At least he penalised them once for it in the second half...



Rant over, Catalans deserved the win, we were poor by and large.

boo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

































Cas were lucky with quite a few decisions too take ur glasses off







=rededited as it was throwing ths board out next time try a few less ooo

Ian smith like it or not made no bad decisions, ok some were pedantic but all were correct at that moment in time and to the letter of the law.....

i hate to admit defeat but once again cas were second best YET AGAIN

Not for the first time I thought the Cas fans showed complete ignorance ... the ref had a good game, the Cas fans simply couldn't understand the CORRECT decision regarding Chase's play the ball when he hadn't even been tackled. But what made me laugh loudest, was when Cats scored a try from a kick over the top ... the Cas fans went mental claiming he was offside and boo-ed and all that stuff ... the video replay showed he was ON SIDE ... but the Cas fans continued to boo and question Smith's parentage! Jeez, the words "thick", "pig", "as" and "plop" sping to mind.

Them 2 were correct, but how about the countless high tackled missed? or no sin binning for persistant high tackling?



Cas were poor, Catalan were poor, so was the ref - crap match all in all.

I think the fans are just getting frustrated with the number of close games that we've lost. We've lost about 5 games by about 2 points this season at home, and the refs have always given one or two decision that cost us.



I've never seen Cas fans so angry.

Cut your post down you idiot.

I did get to the game today, if i was there i'd have be booing myself in the heat the the moment and shouting cheat, like ya do, but watching it on TV shows Smith didnt do that much wrong apart from let countless head shots go, but he no game changing decition went agaisnt us, When Chase was down he was clearliy shouting "play on", yeah it was harsh, but was dealt with by the letter of the law. Only ourselfs to blame again, another lose again at home and again by 2 points, Can we make the play offs? your guess is as good as mine

most of his decisions were spot on but he did miss a lot of high shots from a neutrel

Agree entirely, smith should've punished cats fro the persistant high tackles, but must've left his cards at home tonight, overall we got what we deserved

Re the Chase incident.



Catalans knocked on and chase re-gathered ... no advantage was gained by Cas ... so by right the correct decision was a scrum ... ...... Chase clearly thought he was tackled so played the ball.... the correct way to deal with the confusion was to call no advantage and form a scrum



unfortunatley for us it was one of those days where the right decision got lost in the heat of the moment and Smith got it wrong and awarded a penalty... cats subsequantly went up the field to score what turned out to be the winning try (dosen't that always happen ???).



Overall I think what incensed the crowd was the way all decisions relating to Cas try's were refered to the video ref and some of the cats try's were not, even though there was clearly something to have a look at.



All in all I thought it was a poor game played by two teams who should be at the lower end of the table....... and are ..... says it all for me.