I know he's looked a little weak at times, but I'm pretty sure Carl is not a girl

All entitled to opinions. But Manning aint a scratch on Allen. Allen has more skill in left little toe than Manning. But I accept your view on the Stand off role.

i agree with gilder not big enough!!

Just an opinion on recent form and had mcshane been named i'd have give him a chance this week and rested diskin.

P.s I'm not claiming to be an expert either just squad rotation!!

personally i would drop disco and go with 4 big en's on the bench due to lack of go forward

I agree regarding McShane and Diskin.



That's different from proclaiming a player isn't "good enough" in the face of him becoming a regular in two championship squads coached by two different quality coaches.

In my defence i never did say ablett wasn't good enough it's just the above "poster" asummed that's what i meant re-my selection!!

You don't have to put a defence forward. My thinly vieled disdain was aimed at the fekkwitt I quoted and not you.

Loud and clear!!

1 Brent Webb

2 Scott Donald

3 Lee Smith

4 Keith Senior

5 Ryan Hall

6 Danny McGuire

7 Rob Burrow

8 Kylie Leuluai

9 Danny Buderus

10 Jamie Peacock

11 Jamie Jones Buchanan

12 Ali Lauitiiti

13 Kevin Sinfield

14 Matt Diskin

17 Ian Kirke

18 Carl Ablett

19 Luke Burgess



The team pretty much picks itself.

Depending on how fit Smith is I would swap him with Watkins.

Would like to have seen Ratu and McShane get a run.

What has happened to Ratu is he still with the club?

Clearly he is well down the pecking order even with an injury prone Gibson it seems.

Webb

Donald

Smith

Senior

Hall

Mcguire

Burrow

Peacock

Buderus

Kirke

Jjb

Ali

Sinfield



Burgess

Diskin

Leuleui

Worrall.



Agree with this

I'd go with;



1.Webb

2.Donald

3.Smith

4.Senior

5.Hall

6.McGuire

7.Burrow

8.Leuluai

9.Buderus

10.Peacock

11.Jones-Buchannan

17.Kirke

13.Sinfield



14.Diskin

12.Lauitiiti

18.Ablett

19.Burgess