Challenge cup

Both. Simples

cc for me ,the old trafford thing is a joke ,teams pickin some one to play and all that junk,bring back the floodlit cup lancs cup yorkshire cup john player and give the team who finish 1st the super league cup .more to play for and some of the other teams have a chance other than just 2 things

Challenge Cup for me, just for the whole Wembley day experience, loved it last year, and I will love it again tomorrow whether we win or lose.

we need to win a grand final, other fans wont admit that we are one of the best teams in super league until we have won one aswel as this challenge cup, just got a sneeky feeling leeds are going to win though what ever form they are in they always perform amazing when they have to

challenge cup for the reasons Yed mentioned.. and also that the club gains more financially from winning the challenge cup (apparently)

The Challenge cup is where its at for me because of its history and tradition..

The playoff's are just a sky created thing which they copied from the Aussies,the team that finishes top of the league table at the end of the season should be champions end of...



Fo me its a no brainer



1) Day out in London to watch two teams do battle for the games most historic trophy in a final at Wembley stadium with all its history.



Or



2) A final at a stadium loaned from a football club for the day.



Option 1 for me..

Isn't Wembley predominently a football stadium?



Anyhow, i know i'm not a Wire fan but for me it has to be the Grand Final. The CC is a great trophy to win, dont get me wrong, but i'd rather see my team be crowned Super League Champions, rewarded for providing the entertainment for 27 rounds + play offs.

I´d take the CC.

Challenge Cup

Interesting replies. I too would take the Challenge Cups. However if it was a straight choice between one Grand Final and two Challenge Cups, I'd take the Grand Final. I think if it gets to three or more then you've got to go with the cups because you start to create history. Saints have only won one Grand Final in the last eight seasons but I think of them as having been a dominant side because they won four out of five Challenge Cups between 04 and 08.

Without a shadow of doubt it's the CC for me, for all the reasons that have been expressed within these posts. It's also the travelling down to Wembley thing. the post above sums my opinion up perfectly. I think Wigan should get more recognition for being the best team this year in Super League.