As far as i`m aware Vinnie Anderson is out of contract after this season, Jon Clarke recently signed a new 4 year deal and Michael Monaghan signed a 4 year deal when he joined....Seeing as Clarke and Monaghan are both under contract as i read it and Vinnie Anderson`s will soon be out of contract and his form for us overall has been patchy to say the least, he has also had a lot of injury problems so it makes sense to release Vinnie Anderson given the above.



Thats baased on Michael Monaghan staying but only as a hooker with Micky Higham as the impact hooker hence why i suggested moving Jon Clarke to 13 where he has performed well for us in the past.



Their have been reports as you know about Michael Monaghan possibly wanting to go back to the NRL, i don`t think we would have much trouble in negotiating a release froim his contract if Tony Smith didn`t see him as part of his plans as he would find an NRL club as a hooker without too much of a problem.

But you said release Monaghan.



Its all well and good saying we can negotiate a release but the truth is that it is highly un-likely anybody would match Monaghan's salary and hence we would have to pay the difference which would count on our cap and reduce our spending power elsewhere.



From what I can see it would appear that Monaghan will be here next year.

no TC was warning people so i did a tongue in cheek $%'&* expletive signs sentence without actually saying anything. I think he put the =redBANNED thing as a sarcastic reply.



I was only joking

What about that tax loophole business being closed, hasn't his net income gone down?

Quote Paul Youane="Paul Youane"But you said release Monaghan. Its all well and good saying we can negotiate a release but the truth is that it is highly un-likely anybody would match Monaghan's salary and hence we would have to pay the difference which would count on our cap and reduce our spending power elsewhere.'" If reports like this are true we wouldn`t have to pay Michael Monaghan anything to release him from his contract, Don Furner has claimed that his brother Joel Monaghan said his brother isn`t happy over here. To return to the NRL he would have to take a pay cut or he can stay over here being unhappy on more money, its upto him. www.smh.com.au/news/news/raiders ... 77341.html

Quote Paul Youane="Paul Youane"But you said release Monaghan. Its all well and good saying we can negotiate a release but the truth is that it is highly un-likely anybody would match Monaghan's salary and hence we would have to pay the difference which would count on our cap and reduce our spending power elsewhere.'" If reports like this are true we wouldn`t have to pay Michael Monaghan anything to release him from his contract, Don Furner has claimed that his brother Joel Monaghan said his brother isn`t happy over here. To return to the NRL he would have to take a pay cut or he can stay over here being unhappy on more money, its upto him. www.smh.com.au/news/news/raiders ... 77341.html

Right, so a guy that you have already stated isnt good at distributing the ball yet your claiming he should player hooker where his main duty will be distributing the ball?

Quote Rob Wire="Rob Wire"If reports like this are true we wouldn`t have to pay Michael Monaghan anything to release him from his contract, Don Furner has claimed that his brother Joel Monaghan said his brother isn`t happy over here. To return to the NRL he would have to take a pay cut or he can stay over here being unhappy on more money, its upto him. www.smh.com.au/news/news/raiders ... 77341.html'" That article dates from around the same time when Joel Monaghan was supposedly going to sign for Warrington as Gleeson's replacement next season. I think that Monaghan is a lot happier playing under Tony Smith than he was under Paul Cullen or James Lowes. A lot of things have changed since that article was written. Am I 100% sure he'll be here next season? No but it is infinitely more likely that he will be than say there is of Kevin Sinfield or Thomas Bosc being here.

Quote Rob Wire="Rob Wire"If reports like this are true we wouldn`t have to pay Michael Monaghan anything to release him from his contract, Don Furner has claimed that his brother Joel Monaghan said his brother isn`t happy over here. To return to the NRL he would have to take a pay cut or he can stay over here being unhappy on more money, its upto him. www.smh.com.au/news/news/raiders ... 77341.html'" That article dates from around the same time when Joel Monaghan was supposedly going to sign for Warrington as Gleeson's replacement next season. I think that Monaghan is a lot happier playing under Tony Smith than he was under Paul Cullen or James Lowes. A lot of things have changed since that article was written. Am I 100% sure he'll be here next season? No but it is infinitely more likely that he will be than say there is of Kevin Sinfield or Thomas Bosc being here.

Completely different kind of distribution from dummy-half than it is from first or second receiver.

Not all hookers are distributors in the way that your thinking they are, a scrum half and a hooker have totally different roles and a totally different passing game.



Look at Roby and Cunningham, both are quick thinking hookers that like to make the quick runs from acting half which then catches slow defenders on the back foot and makes their team a good 20+ yards.



I wouldn`t say that Kieron Cunningham is best known for spraying 20 yard passes all over the field, a hooker mainly has a short passing game to bring the forwards onto the ball, at scrum half its a totally different kind of passing game, its the long distribution that Michael Monaghan struggles with as his passing at that range is awful at best.



Michal Monaghan seems to be a better player when he doesn`t have to stop and think about who he should pass too, he is a far better when playing on instinct and running the ball from acting half and is more suited to popping a short pass to a supporting player than the longer distribution game of a scrum half.

Im happy for him to stay but surely he should be moved into the 9 shirt.

TS confirms that Monas will still be here in 2010 in the post match interview after the hull game. Check the official site.



Personally, I think he's a hooker and never in this world a 7 and never will be. Hopefully Myler is the first choice 7 next year (alongside Briers it would seem).

That must mean there is zero chance of Sinfield joining us?