CNUT

All "in your opinion" which is the problem with the rule about taking a player into touch, other people saw it differently. (wasn't attacking your opinion, just using it as evidence of the confusion)

That's fair enough.

I can understand how someone in the West stand might have viewed the Hicks try differently as they may have seen it slightly from behind, but we were right above it in the corner and he grounded the ball. It was a great piece of finishing IMO.

tbf my issue is mainly the Yeaman thing, rules that are "open to interpretation" then it's wrong, certainly on something as fundamental as what constitues top drawer defence.

Saw the Hicks try on Sky last night and you are right it was a great finish.

My only doubt at the time (from the West Stand

) was whether there had been any contact with the touch line. He grounded it exceptionally well in such a small space

What was the penalty count on Monday? I asked this on a separate thread but either no one knows or cares or I typed in invisible text! I could only remember one for us after about 60 minutes or so. If that was the case then Warrington clearly have improved on their average of 8 up to round 6 according to the fairplay index which funnily enough is the same as our average. I'm sure we missed some , it couldn't be just one , could it?

Stated clearly on Boots N All that the tackle was completed and that's why the penalty was awared for dragging into touch after held had been called

I was at the game as a neutral and the first half was the worst refereeing I have ever seen. Ganson was dire with the amount of forward passes/ knock ons he missed. You could see that the Hull players had become so demoralised by it that the tries by Warrington in the 2nd half were inevitable. Warrington had the same rub of the green against Castleford early on in the season IIRC.

Took my lady friend (Giants fan) to the game. Spent the entire match shaking her head asking how the hell Ganson gets away with it. In her words ' Never seen a ref so biased'.

Exactly, it was bad.

Not as bad as halibut was at dave whelan's place when we played you the other week